YOUR top 10 City players from the last 20 years???

[Parrot]

Not necessarily the BEST ability wise but the ones who hold a special place in your hearttup:

In no particular order...

1. Stuart McCall
2. Peter Beagrie
3. John Hendrie
4. Greg Abbott
5. Wayne Jacobs
6. John Dreyer
7. Nigel Pepper
8. Lee Duxbury
9. Edhino
10.Jamie Lawrence

I'll probably kick mesen when someone puts someone i've forgotten on their list, but the guys above somehow just jump straight out of my memory bankstup:

[Joe_Brett]

No order

1. Stuart McCall
2. Peter Beagrie
3. John Hendrie
4. David Weatherhall
5. Wayne Jacobs
6. Mark Bower
7. Damien Stewart
8. Lee Mills
9. Edhino
10.Jamie Lawrence

[king billy]

I'm sneaking Bobby Campbell on my list - even though strictly that would make it best players in the last 21 years.....;)

In no particular order....

1 - stuart mccall
2 - john hendrie
3 - peter jackson
4 - mark ellis
5 - bobby campbell
6 - greg abbott
7 - lee duxbury
8 - peter beagrie
9 - karl goddard
10 - edinho

Just missing out - leigh palin, sean mccarthy, jamie lawrence, don goodman, gavin oliver, dave evans and paul tomlinson.....

[Parrot]

Aye Tommo would be up there for goalkeepers ...he wasn't the best but he certainly endeared himself to the City fanstup:...we'll forget about his blip at Luton in the quarter finals though!:rolleyes:

[matnab]

Don Goodman - for city KB???

McCall
Hendrie
Beags
McCarthy
Kennedy
Richards
Mills
Tinnion
Walsh
Youds

Not necessarily the ten best, but 10 of the players that made the most impact for me. Aizlewood and John Taylor just missed out;)

[tony d]

Wouldnt mind seeing this lot play together in their primes...
1. Donovan Ricketts

2. Dean Richards
3. David Wetherall
4. Mark Bower

5.Edhino
6.Lee Duxbury
7.Stuart McCall
8.Peter Beagrie

9Robbie Blake.
10.John Hendrie
11.Lee Mills

[Wicker Man]

Wouldnt mind seeing this lot play together in their primes...
1. Donovan Ricketts

2. Dean Richards
3. David Wetherall
4. Mark Bower

5.Edhino
6.Lee Duxbury
7.Stuart McCall
8.Peter Beagrie

9Robbie Blake.
10.John Hendrie
11.Lee Mills

do they not teach you to count under her majestys service?;)


In no particular order...

1. Stuart McCall
2. Peter Beagrie
3. John Hendrie
4. Andy Cooke
5. Wayne Jacobs
6. John Dreyer
7. Nigel Pepper
8. Claus B Jorgensen
9. Edhino
10.Damian Stewart

[madridbantam]

1 mccall
2 carbone
3 waddle
4 blake (despite his current allegiances)
5 wethers
6 lawrence
7 palin
8 neville southall, just for having guts
9 ormondroyd
10 hendrie, even though he mad me pay 1p for an autograph

[Wicker Man]

10 hendrie, even though he mad me pay 1p for an autograph

:D jump: Why?

[madridbantam]

i dunno, but he came in to my school and we all had to pay 1p if we wanted an autograph. demanding money off of 10 year olds, tight fisted get.

[king billy]

Don Goodman - for city KB???

Aye - why not? Quality player.....tup:

Wish we'd kept hold of him longer, went on to bigger and better things after showing his early promise here...

[tony d]

do they not teach you to count under her majestys service?;)


In no particular order...

1. Stuart McCall
2. Peter Beagrie
3. John Hendrie
4. Andy Cooke
5. Wayne Jacobs
6. John Dreyer
7. Nigel Pepper
8. Claus B Jorgensen
9. Edhino
10.Damian Stewart

They do but for anyone with a hint of a brain you can see i set mine up as a team...A team consisting of 11 players not 10....Ricketts would be the first off the list..Sorry that was hard for you to work out mate....tup:

Wouldnt mind seeing this lot play together in their primes...
1. Donovan Ricketts

2. Dean Richards
3. David Wetherall
4. Mark Bower

5.Edhino
6.Lee Duxbury
7.Stuart McCall
8.Peter Beagrie

9Robbie Blake.
10.John Hendrie
11.Lee Mills

[Wicker Man]

They do but for anyone with a hint of a brain you can see i set mine up as a team...A team consisting of 11 players not 10....Ricketts would be the first off the list..Sorry that was hard for you to work out mate....tup:

i know, hence the :rolleyes:

[Zonnebloem]

Difficult to see how you could leave Waddle and Carbone out of the best players.

As I understand it, it's best players, whether this be 10 strikers or 10 keepers. 10 players don't quite make a football team.

I'd add Gunnar Halle as the best right back I've seen in C&B.

[beerbantam]

I'm sneaking Bobby Campbell on my list - even though strictly that would make it best players in the last 21 years.....;)

In no particular order....

1 - stuart mccall
2 - john hendrie
3 - peter jackson
4 - mark ellis
5 - bobby campbell
6 - greg abbott
7 - lee duxbury
8 - peter beagrie
9 - karl goddard
10 - edinho

Just missing out - leigh palin, sean mccarthy, jamie lawrence, don goodman, gavin oliver, dave evans and paul tomlinson.....


Lol, Im surprised you havent picked Wetherall there mate!jawdrop: :p :p

[Yeadon Bantam]

Id have doyle!

[mrsjdtobe]

Yes we know love: :rolleyes:

[BantamMenace]

Gunnar Halle? he was awuful at defending from what i remember, still a good guy and will go down in city history as the guy who set up the goal that kept us in the prem but he wasnt rite clever at defending.

[king billy]

Lol, Im surprised you havent picked Wetherall there mate!jawdrop: :p :p

lol.....:D

One thing i've noticed tho mate - not one persons picked Dean Windass.....tup: tup:

[Tallinnbantam]

No one has picked Paul Jewell either?! I'm toying with the idea of mentioning Robbie James, Ian Banks, 'Mad' Mick Kennedy and Wes Reid..but I'll probably get laughed at!

[Rambo]

1 - Stuart Mccall
2 - John Hendrie
3 - Chris Pearce (For his dancing in the net)
4 - Greg Abbott
5 - Brian Tinnion
6 - Lee Duxbury
7 - Dean Richards
8 - Peter Beagrie
9 - Chris Waddle
10 - Benito Carbone

[Superfatbantam]

I'd add Gunnar Halle as the best right back I've seen in C&B.

Did Gunnar fill in for me that week I missed then?jawdrop:

In terms of impact and memories, not skill:

1) Stuart McCall
2) Peter Beagire
3) Wayne Jacobs
4) Mark Stallard (Wembley goal)
5) Des Hamilton (Wembley Goal)
6) Karl Shutt (Blackpool performance)
7) Robbie Blake
8) Lee Mills
9) Nigel Pepper
10) Edinho

[matnab]

Aye - why not? Quality player.....tup:

Wish we'd kept hold of him longer, went on to bigger and better things after showing his early promise here...

Each to their own I suppose. He certainly did go on to better things though. As far as I can recall he spent most of his time at City either on his arse or offside?:)

Robbie James is a cracking call Tallinn.

[mrsjdtobe]

In no order : :D


1. Schwarzer
2. Bruno
3. Beagrie
4. Edhino
5. Youds
6. Mills
7. McCall
8. Whalley
9. Shutt
10. Steiner

[beerbantam]

1 - Peter Beagrie
2 - Dean Windass
3 - Stanley Victor Collymoor
4 - Dean Richards
5 - Nicky Summerbee
6 - Jermaine Johnson
7 - Matt Etherington
8 - Gus Ulenbeek
9 - Jamie Lawrence
10 - Stuart McCall

[king billy]

1 - Peter Beagrie
2 - Dean Windass
3 - Stanley Victor Collymoor
4 - Dean Richards
5 - Nicky Summerbee
6 - Jermaine Johnson
7 - Matt Etherington
8 - Gus Ulenbeek
9 - Jamie Lawrence
10 - Stuart McCall

I see what you've done there mate - snuck a few funny ones in the middle!!....tup: :D

You weren't serious were you?....:eek:

[beerbantam]

I see what you've done there mate - snuck a few funny ones in the middle!!....tup: :D

You weren't serious were you?....:eek:

Dont know what you mean, best crosser of the ball(best creator) we have had in last 10 years was Summerbee, Etherington & JJ along with Beags have been the most exiting to watch, and Gus for a similar reason - with all the dross we've had at RB he stands out like a sore thumb to me as one i enjoyed watching!!

[Jantje]

1 - Peter Beagrie
2 - John Hendrie
3 - Chris Waddle
4 - Edinho
5 - Eddie Youds
6 - Wayne Jacobs
7 - Robert Steiner
8 - John Dreyer
9 - Jamie Lawrence
10 - Stuart McCall

[meelin]

1 - McCall
2 - Beagrie
3 - Walsh
4 - Hendrie
5 - Mills
6 - Blake
7 - Edinhio
8 - Singleton
9 - Bruno
10 - A toss up between Waddle and Carbone, with perhaps Waddle just getting the nod because of his goal at Everton.

Bobby Campbell would have been on the list if the time scale were longer than the last 20 years.

[meelin]

1 - McCall
2 - Beagrie
3 - Walsh
4 - Hendrie
5 - Mills
6 - Blake
7 - Edinhio
8 - Singleton
9 - Bruno
10 - A toss up between Waddle and Carbone, with perhaps Waddle just getting the nod because of his goal at Everton.

Bobby Campbell would have been on the list if the time scale were longer than the last 20 years.

Blimey, I forgot Greg Abbottjawdrop:

[king billy]

Dont know what you mean, best crosser of the ball(best creator) we have had in last 10 years was Summerbee, Etherington & JJ along with Beags have been the most exiting to watch, and Gus for a similar reason - with all the dross we've had at RB he stands out like a sore thumb to me as one i enjoyed watching!!

Its your list mate so its up to you - surprised me thats all.....
Stephen Wright would be a good shout at right back, he was faultless during the premier league promotion campaign, pity he was always chuffing injured tho after that.....
Agree re Summerbee's crossing, but he was a lazy ***** thought he was better than everyone else and wasn't a team player, all that and he also had a bad attitude, mind you he'd be in good company on your list with Windass and Collymore.....;) tup: :D

[Parrot]

1 - Peter Beagrie
2 - Dean Windass
3 - Stanley Victor Collymoor roflmao:
4 - Dean Richards
5 - Nicky Summerbee
6 - Jermaine Johnson
7 - Matt Etherington
8 - Gus Ulenbeek
9 - Jamie Lawrence
10 - Stuart McCall

Why dont you stick Peter Costello in there too Ben?:eek: ....He once scored past L**ds, even better it was at Bellend road! :rolleyes:

[beerbantam]

Why dont you stick Peter Costello in there too Ben?:eek: ....He once scored past L**ds, even better it was at Bellend road! :rolleyes:

Not in the last 10 years though mate!!

Collymoor's a legend anyway !!tup:

[Jantje]

Why dont you stick Peter Costello in there too Ben?:eek: ....He once scored past L**ds, even better it was at Bellend road! :rolleyes:


That was a great goal, and we got bricked by the local inbreds after the game as well!!!!

[king billy]

Abbo scored aswell did he not? - Abbott and Costello on the scoresheet - bet its been the question on many a quiz night up and down the land since.....:D

Ah - the old lowfields stand - dodging the sharpened two pence coins, and being penned in like animals - them were't days!!...

[Parrot]

Not in the last 10 years though mate!!

Collymoor's a legend anyway !!tup:

True....but i thought it was your best players from the last 20 years:rolleyes:

Back to costello, it was indeed a great goal, we were packed in behind the goal in the South Stand that night & got a perfect viewtup: ...winning 3 times only to draw 3-3 with the Sh*te scoring a late equalizer:( ....Can't wait for next season now!!!jump: